Mastering leadership: Why agile and modern approaches define tomorrow's winners
Are you prepared to lead your organization through chaos and uncertainty?
Leadership today is no longer about maintaining the status quo but about navigating a landscape that demands adaptability and foresight. As companies grapple with evolving challenges, the choice between agile leadership and modern leadership becomes a defining factor in their success.
My article delves into the core advantages and disadvantages of these two leadership styles, empowering decision-makers to chart the right course for their organizations.
Understanding agile leadership
Agile leadership stems from the Agile Manifesto, originally developed for software development. It emphasizes adaptability, collaboration, and customer-centricity. Agile leaders inspire teams to embrace change, experiment, and continuously improve.
Key Principles:
- Flexibility: Agile leaders adapt to changing circumstances, pivoting strategies as needed.
- Empowerment: Teams are encouraged to make decisions autonomously.
- Collaboration: Cross-functional teamwork and open communication are prioritized.
- Iterative processes: Progress is made through small, incremental steps with frequent feedback.
Advantages
- Increased adaptability:
Agile leadership allows organizations to respond swiftly to market changes and customer needs. Agile leaders foster a culture of continuous feedback and iterative decision-making, enabling rapid responses to dynamic environments.
For example, Spotify uses Agile “squads” to iterate on user features, adapting quickly based on real-time data and user feedback. Similarly, Google’s adoption of OKRs (Objectives and Key Results) empowers teams to pivot strategies while maintaining alignment with overarching goals.
Companies with Agile practices are 60% faster in decision-making than traditional organizations (McKinsey, 2023). - Enhanced team engagement:
Empowering employees fosters innovation and job satisfaction. - Customer focus: Agile leaders ensure customer feedback drives decision-making, improving product-market fit.
Disadvantages
- Risk of chaos:
Without clear boundaries, agility can lead to disorganization. For instance, during the early adoption of Agile methodologies at a prominent e-commerce company, overlapping responsibilities among cross-functional teams led to missed deadlines and inconsistent product features. This disarray was eventually resolved by introducing clear guidelines on team roles and decision-making authority, demonstrating the critical balance required for Agile to succeed. - High dependency on team dynamics:
Agile success hinges on team collaboration, which can falter without strong interpersonal relationships. - Resource intensity:
Regular iterations and constant adjustments require significant time and resources.
Understanding modern leadership
Modern leadership encompasses a range of contemporary approaches designed to address today’s business challenges. It often integrates elements of servant leadership, transformational leadership, and data-driven decision-making.
Key Principles:
- Vision-driven: Leaders provide clear long-term goals and inspire teams to align with them.
- Employee well-being: A focus on mental health, diversity, and work-life balance.
- Data-informed decisions: Leveraging analytics to guide strategies.
- Technology integration: Utilizing digital tools to streamline processes.
Advantages
- Strategic focus:
Clear vision and structured goals ensure alignment across the organization. For example, under Satya Nadella’s leadership, Microsoft underwent a significant cultural shift focusing on cloud computing and collaboration. This clear strategic vision allowed the company to regain market leadership, achieving a 258% increase in stock value over five years and positioning Microsoft as a dominant player in the technology sector.
70% of high-performing organizations attribute their success to clear leadership strategies (Deloitte, 2022). - Sustainability:
By prioritizing employee well-being, modern leaders reduce turnover and build resilient teams. - Scalability:
Structured approaches make it easier to replicate success across departments or regions.
Disadvantages
- Slower adaptation:
Long-term focus may hinder quick responses to sudden changes. For example, Kodak’s reluctance to shift from traditional film to digital photography illustrates this drawback. While the company had the technological capability, its commitment to existing revenue streams delayed adaptation, leading to a significant loss of market share when competitors quickly embraced digital solutions. - Potential disconnect:
Over-reliance on data and technology can overshadow the human aspect of leadership. - Resistance to change:
Established hierarchies may struggle to accommodate new ideas or pivot strategies.
Agile vs. modern leadership: A direct comparison
Trends and insights
The choice between agile and modern leadership often depends on the organization’s industry, size, and objectives.
For instance, agile leadership thrives in tech startups where rapid product iterations and market responsiveness are critical. Companies like Spotify and Airbnb exemplify this, using Agile frameworks to innovate and deliver customer-centric solutions swiftly.
Conversely, modern leadership excels in industries such as large-scale manufacturing or pharmaceuticals, where structured processes and long-term planning are essential. For example, Johnson & Johnson’s focus on strategic leadership ensures compliance, scalability, and sustained innovation in their global operations.
Notably:
- Hybrid models:
Increasingly, companies are combining Agile principles with modern leadership frameworks to achieve balance. For example, leaders set long-term visions while empowering teams to use Agile methods for execution. - Cultural shifts:
Younger workforces value flexibility and purpose, favoring Agile practices. However, larger organizations often require the scalability and structure of modern leadership. - Technology as a bridge:
Advanced tools such as AI and automation enable both approaches to coexist, facilitating agility while maintaining strategic oversight.
Making the right choice
As a leader in the field of digital transformation, I’ve observed that success lies not in choosing one approach over the other but in integrating the best of both worlds.
For instance:
- Agile leadership excels in project-based work, innovation, and customer-centric initiatives.
- Modern leadership shines in scaling operations, strategic planning, and fostering a sustainable work environment.
To thrive in today’s complex business landscape, leaders should:
- Assess organizational needs:
Understand your team’s strengths, challenges, and industry demands. - Cultivate agility:
Embrace adaptability without compromising on structure. - Leverage data wisely:
Use analytics to support, not replace, human judgment. - Invest in culture:
Create an environment where both approaches can flourish.
An example from the field
Let me show you an example, the agile transformation of ING Bank.
ING Bank successfully achieved its agile transformation through several practical steps that fostered innovation, efficiency, and customer focus. Here are specific examples of how they implemented Agile practices:
1. Adoption of the “Spotify Model” for team structure
ING reorganized its workforce into “squads”, “tribes”, and “chapters”—inspired by Spotify’s Agile approach:
- Squads: Small, autonomous teams with a clear mission (e.g., improving the mobile banking app). Each squad consisted of 8-10 people who combined roles like developers, designers, and marketers.
- Tribes: Groups of squads working on related tasks to align overall strategy (e.g., customer experience across digital platforms).
- Chapters: Communities of experts in a particular skill area, ensuring knowledge sharing and consistency (e.g., front-end developers exchanging coding standards).
This structure removed hierarchical bottlenecks and empowered teams to make decisions faster. For instance, ING Netherlands accelerated the development of its digital banking services by reducing product cycle times from months to weeks.
2. Customer-centric focus with Agile principles
ING placed a strong emphasis on customer value by incorporating Agile principles like iterative feedback loops and Minimum Viable Products (MVPs):
- Teams delivered small increments of features, tested them with customers, and iterated based on feedback
- For example, ING’s mobile banking app was redesigned iteratively. Features like facial recognition for secure login were tested on small user groups before wider rollout.
- The app’s user adoption grew significantly, as ING could continuously release customer-driven improvements instead of relying on long, monolithic development cycles.
3. Shift in culture: From control to trust
Leadership at ING adopted a servant-leadership approach, encouraging experimentation and removing traditional “command-and-control” oversight:
- Managers acted as coaches who removed obstacles for teams rather than micromanaging tasks.
- Teams were free to experiment with new technologies or processes to solve problems.
- ING introduced a Voice Banking feature using AI-driven technology, a project led by a cross-functional squad. The team experimented and tested voice recognition capabilities without awaiting top-down approval for every step.
- The teams felt a sense of ownership and accountability, leading to faster, innovative outcomes.
4. Streamlining processes using Agile frameworks
ING replaced traditional waterfall project management with Agile frameworks like Scrum and Kanban to reduce delays and improve collaboration.
- Daily stand-up meetings, sprints, and retrospectives became standard practice to ensure transparency, accountability, and continuous improvement.
- A cross-functional team improving ING’s online mortgage application process used Scrum to streamline steps. By working in short sprints, they cut the mortgage approval time from 3 weeks to just a few days.
- This change resulted in faster delivery times and improved customer satisfaction.
5. Upskilling and training employees
To ensure the Agile transformation succeeded, ING invested heavily in training its workforce:
- Employees received Agile coaching and participated in workshops to understand new roles, such as Product Owners and Scrum Masters.
- Cross-functional skills were encouraged to increase flexibility and collaboration within squads.
- ING held large-scale training programs, helping teams shift mindsets from siloed roles to collaborative product ownership.
6. Use of digital tools for collaboration
ING leveraged technology tools to enable collaboration across geographically dispersed teams:
- Tools like Jira, Confluence, and Slack facilitate transparent task management, communication, and documentation.
- The teams could efficiently plan, execute, and monitor tasks, even when team members worked remotely.
The key outcomes of ING’s Agile transformation
- Faster delivery:
The time-to-market for digital products decreased significantly. - Enhanced innovation:
Teams experimented and learned quickly, leading to solutions like improved mobile banking and AI-based services. - Increased customer satisfaction:
Iterative releases focused on customer feedback resulted in highly tailored solutions.
By creating an Agile culture and empowering teams, ING Bank became a leader in digital banking transformation, setting a benchmark for the industry.
Leadership today demands recognizing that moment and leading with both agility and modernity.
As Winston Churchill once said, “To each, there comes in their lifetime a special moment when they are figuratively tapped on the shoulder and offered the chance to do a very special thing, unique to their talents.”
By thoughtfully blending agile and modern leadership principles, organizations can achieve sustained growth, innovation, and resilience—turning challenges into opportunities and uncertainties into triumphs.
Are you interested in more insights on navigating leadership and digital transformation? Please feel free to connect with me.
Schedule a call directly in my calendar
or contact me via WhatsApp or email
Don’t forget to subscribe to my newsletter.
You will receive the latest insights on digital transformation, marketing automation & AI, and digital marketing. Stay updated with expert tips, trends, and highlights that help you navigate the digital landscape and accelerate your success. Don’t miss out on the news that could transform your business.
Join my community today & always be up-to-date!